In treatment, I became very close with a older woman who had what’s called Dissociative Identity Disorder (what used to be called Multiple Personality Disorder). I won’t use her real name, so let’s call her Debbie. From Wikipedia: “DID is a mental disorder on the dissociative spectrum characterized by at least two distinct and relatively enduring identities or dissociated personality states that alternately control a person’s behavior, and is accompanied by memory impairment for important information not explained by ordinary forgetfulness.” Yes, Debbie had multiple personalities. I met three that were separate parts of herself that came out when she was stressed or fearful. Sometimes she went to sleep as herself and woke up as someone else. Sometimes, mid-conversation, her behavior and body language would suddenly change dramatically as if she’d spontaneously transformed into another person. It was hard to predict who would show up on a daily basis or when she would turn into someone else.
Debbie, herself, was a very shy and insecure person, though incredibly sweet and caring. She has the biggest heart, supporting and loving each and every one of us, but always neglecting to love herself. She felt like a burden to her loved ones for the pain and stress she caused them and as a result, had learned to view herself as nothing more than a nuisance. One of the personalities was a more outgoing and bubbly version of Debbie. We’ll name her “Deb.” Deb was very confident and strong-willed. It seemed that she would take pride in overcoming Debbie in order to become the dominant personality for however long she was present. She was the bully, the conquerer, the dictator. Honestly, Deb scared me. She would make comments about her hatred for Debbie, calling her weak and inferior. At one point when I was talking with her, Deb threatened to kill Debbie.
Another personality that we’ll call “Deborah,” was a quiet and orderly person. She was constantly active, tidying the common room, putting away books and papers, throwing away trash. I didn’t see her as much as Deb, but when she was around, she would barely speak aside from saying short sentences like, “I need to clean,” “I’ll put that away,” “I can do that.”
The final personality that I met was that of a little girl. I only met her once and when I did, she was crying and shaking in my arms. It’s believed that DID evolves from childhood abuse of some kind, some trauma that seemingly broke the person’s identity into several pieces, like shards of broken glass. I believe that was true in Debbie’s case (though she claimed to remember nothing traumatic in her childhood), because on the night that I met this little girl, another woman in the treatment center had thrown a tantrum and started throwing things at the walls. When Debbie heard a loud bang, she suddenly shrieked, grabbed a hold of my arm and pulled me into an abandoned corner of the building in which we were lodged. She cowered in the shadows and pulled me into a tight hug, burying her head in my shoulder. I felt the tears seep through the fabric of my shirt. Every time she heard a noise or a footstep, she would whimper and jump. Over and over, in a tiny child-like voice, she would murmur “no, no, no.” I could tell from the shuddering of her body that shook my own with its sobs, that she was utterly terrified. It seemed from the occasional darting of her eyes and glances over her shoulder that she was waiting for someone, perhaps a past abuser.
My experience with Debbie was both frightening and heartbreaking. I loved this woman dearly and still do. She is such a beautiful, kind-hearted and gentle person whom I will always cherish having had the chance to know. She was a comfort to me during the most difficult part of my life whilst in treatment. She was my best friend behind those locked doors. I hated seeing her suffer. It pained me so much to tell her about times when she had been a different personality, events and periods of which she had no recollection whatsoever. The fear and shame in her eyes for being the way she was broke my heart even further than it had already been broken.
I’m writing about Debbie’s story not only to spread awareness about the reality and hardships experienced by those with mental illness, but also because I’ve found that I actually relate to her in many ways. Of course, I rarely dissociate or have periods of lost time, nor do I have personalities that are noticeably not my own or that exist completely outside of my consciousness… But I have felt as if there are different parts of myself that think and act in different ways. For example, I’ve struggled with dislodging what I’ve come to call my “sick identity,” that which wants me to stay in my addictions and disorders until they kill me. This identity abuses me in every way possible: verbally, psychologically, spiritually and physically. She didn’t want me to survive. She didn’t want me to feel joy, peace, hope. She wanted me dead. In recovery, I started to develop my healthy identity, that which could find small pieces of value in myself, appreciate my skills and talents. I started to consider that I deserved to live, to enjoy things, to love and be loved. Since then, it has felt sort of like two separate personalities. Certain days, I would hate myself and others, I would be okay with the person I was becoming. Sometimes, I would act on behaviors and hours later, I would feel regret and anger at the part of myself that motivated those behaviors. Thankfully, the healthy part of myself seems to becoming more and more dominant as I gain more time in recovery and sobriety. That other part of me, however, is not so easily subdued. She comes out from time to time, her voice echoes in my mind, egging me on to use behaviors or to drink.
Another part of Debbie’s story that I found relevant in my own life is the treatment for her condition, for DID. Therapists don’t necessarily intend to rid the person of these other personalities. Instead, they seek to integrate them, to unite them into one, solid identity. In a way, I feel like I have the same goal. I don’t really want to rid myself of my sick self completely. Though yes, she hurt me, she abused me, she damn near killed me… she also, in a way, saved me. My behaviors and using, though unhealthy in the long run, kept me alive in the moment, helped me to cope with what seemed to be unbearable. They were the only tools I had, the only ways I knew how to deal with pain and distress. Had I not had these behaviors, I might not have been able to endure the pain. I might have given up long ago. They made me feel secure the way order made Deborah feel secure, they made me feel confident the way jokes and attention made Deb feel that way, they made me feel protected the way hiding made the little girl feel protected. The irony in addiction is that what makes us feel safe is actually killing us. We just don’t know any better.
So instead of erasing that part of myself, I want to hold onto parts of her. I want to appreciate her for doing the best she could to help me to endure, to survive. I want to use her determination, focus and commitment towards recovery. I want to remember her and honor her, because though I no longer need her behaviors, she will always be a part of me. In the end, she has made me stronger.
I’m so grateful for having met “Debbie.” She showed me that hope can live on in the midst of the most desperate and agonizing circumstances. She showed me that despite having these illnesses, disorders, or addictions, we don’t have to let them define us. We are still ourselves underneath all of the pain and confusion.
Though so many of us are broken and fragmented due to our pasts, hope is the glue that can put all of the pieces back together. It is possible to become whole again.